Every autumn the same question comes up: should I just fit gutter guards and be done with it? They are sold as the end of blocked gutters, and for some houses they really do help. For others they are money spent on a problem they cannot solve. Here is a straight answer on whether gutter guards are worth it in the UK, from people who see what is inside gutters every week.
Not sure what is blocking your gutters?
We check inside with a camera and tell you honestly whether guards would help.
The short answer: gutter guards can be worth it if your home sits under large-leaved trees, because they keep the big debris out. They are not worth it if you expect never to clean your gutters again. Fine silt, seeds and moss still get through or sit on top, so guarded gutters need checking and cleaning too, just less often.
What are gutter guards?
A gutter guard is anything fitted in or over a gutter to stop debris getting in while still letting rainwater through. You will also see them sold as gutter covers, leaf guards, gutter mesh or gutter brushes. They all make the same promise: fewer blockages and less maintenance.
The main types of gutter guard in the UK
Brush guards
These look like a long bottle brush lying in the gutter, and are often called hedgehog guards. They are cheap and take minutes to fit. Leaves sit on top of the bristles and blow away, at least in theory. In practice the bristles also trap small debris, and after a couple of years the brush itself can become the blockage.
Mesh and screen guards
A strip of plastic or metal mesh clips over the top of the gutter. Large leaves cannot get in. Smaller things can: seeds, pine needles, blossom and the gritty moss that comes off roof tiles all work their way through the holes.
Foam inserts
A wedge of porous foam fills the gutter. Water soaks through and debris stays on top. The trouble is that foam holds moisture, so moss and weeds can root directly into it, and it tends to break down in sunlight after a few years.
Fine micro-mesh and solid covers
These are the premium options: a very fine stainless mesh, or a solid hood that water curls around. They keep out far more than the cheaper types. They also cost far more, and in very heavy rain water can shoot straight over the top instead of dropping into the gutter.
The benefits of gutter guards
- They stop large leaves, which is the main cause of sudden blockages in autumn.
- They keep downpipes clearer, because the big debris never reaches the outlet.
- They can stretch the time between cleans on properties surrounded by trees.
- They discourage birds from nesting in the gutter.
The drawbacks nobody mentions on the packaging
- They do not stop fine debris. Silt, seeds and roof grit still build up underneath, out of sight.
- Debris sits on top instead. A mat of wet leaves or moss on a guard blocks water just as well as one inside the gutter.
- They make cleaning harder. Most guards have to come off before the gutter can be cleaned properly, which adds time and cost.
- They hide problems. You cannot see a blockage forming under a cover. The first sign is often an overflow. (Here are the 7 signs of blocked gutters to watch for.)
- They do nothing about moss. If your roof is mossy, the moss simply lands on the guard and grows there.
So, are gutter guards worth the money?
It depends on what is blocking your gutters.
Worth considering if you have large deciduous trees overhanging the roof, your gutters fill with whole leaves every autumn, and you are happy to have the guards checked from time to time.
Probably not worth it if your blockages come from moss, pine needles or fine silt, if your property has no trees close by, or if you are expecting a fit-and-forget solution. In those cases you will pay for the guards and still pay for cleaning.
If moss is the problem, guards are the wrong fix
A lot of the gutters we clear in Bristol are not full of leaves at all. They are full of moss that has rolled off the roof. No guard solves that, because the source is still sitting on the tiles above.
The fix that works is dealing with the roof. After roof cleaning and moss removal with a biocide treatment, there is no moss left to fall, and unless leaves from nearby trees collect in them, the gutters can stay clear on the inside for years. We also clean the gutters free of charge when we clean a roof, so both jobs are done in one visit.
Gutter guards vs regular gutter cleaning: the cost
Guards are priced by the metre and the better systems are not cheap, particularly once fitting is included. Against that, a professional gutter clean for a terraced house starts from £110 (see our gutter cleaning cost guide). For most homes, a clean once a year costs less over time than a quality guard system that still needs maintaining.
Our honest advice
Before spending money on guards, find out what is actually in your gutters. If it is leaves from a big tree next door, a decent mesh guard can help. If it is moss or silt, save your money and put it towards cleaning the gutters, or the roof.
When we carry out gutter cleaning in Bristol, we use a camera on the pole to look inside the gutter, so we can show you what is causing the blockage and give you a straight answer on whether guards would help. You can read how that works in our comparison of gutter vacuum and ladder cleaning.
Gutter guards: frequently asked questions
Do gutter guards really work?
They work well against large leaves. They are much less effective against fine silt, seeds, pine needles and moss, which either pass through or collect on top of the guard.
Do you still need to clean gutters with guards fitted?
Yes, just less often. Fine debris still builds up under the guard and leaves can mat on top of it, so guarded gutters should still be checked regularly.
What is the best type of gutter guard?
Fine micro-mesh guards keep out the most debris but cost the most. Brush and foam guards are cheap but tend to trap debris and need replacing sooner.
Will gutter guards stop moss blocking my gutters?
No. Moss from the roof lands on the guard and can grow there. The lasting fix is to remove the moss from the roof and treat it.
Book a gutter clean and camera check
Fixed price, ladder-free, with a biocide treatment included.